IL· Season 2026
Max Anderson's three-run homer erased Louisville's no-hit bid as Toledo Mud Hens beat Louisville Bats 4-3 despite being out-hit 7-3.
Match Analysis
AI SummaryHow It Unfolded
Sam Benschoter, making his first start since 21 June, was dominant. He walked one and struck out three over three hitless innings. Kevin Abel followed with 2.1 scoreless frames, extending the collective no-hitter into the sixth.
Louisville broke through in the fourth against Toledo starter Josh Wolf. Edwin Arroyo singled up the middle for the game's first hit, and Juan Brito immediately doubled off the left-field wall to score him. Ivan Johnson singled to right to bring home Brito, and after a caught stealing and a walk, Will Banfield lined an RBI single to right, scoring Michael Chavis for a 3-0 lead.
Francisco Urbaez singled in the fifth for his 250th career hit with the Bats, but the lead evaporated in the sixth.
The Turning Point
Abel walked two of the first three batters in the sixth before Chase Solesky entered. Solesky's first pitch of the game — a 1-0 offering — was crushed by Max Anderson deep into the left-field seats for a three-run homer, the Mud Hens' first hit of the night. The game was tied 3-3.
Toledo grabbed the lead in the eighth. Jace Jung doubled off the first-base bag against Anthony Misiewicz, and Josue Briceño followed with a line-drive single to centre that scored Jung and gave the Mud Hens a 4-3 edge.
Key Performers
Max Anderson (Toledo): The second baseman's 13th homer of the season was the decisive blow — a three-run shot on a first-pitch fastball that erased a near-flawless Bats bullpen performance.
Sam Benschoter (Louisville): Three hitless innings with three strikeouts in his first outing in nearly two months. The right-hander retired nine of the ten batters he faced.
Francisco Urbaez (Louisville): The only Bats hitter with a multi-hit game (2-for-4, double), including his 250th career hit for Louisville.
Beau Brieske (Toledo): Earned the win (2-0) with 1.1 scoreless innings of relief, stranding a runner inherited from Brenan Hanifee.
Player of the Match: Max Anderson — 1-for-4, HR (13), 3 RBI. His three-run homer flipped a 3-0 deficit into a tie game and changed the entire complexion of the contest.
By the Numbers — Interpreted
The box score tells a rare story: Toledo won despite being out-hit 7-3. The Mud Hens' three hits generated four runs — a 1.33 runs-per-hit rate that reflects two clutch swings in the sixth and eighth. Anderson's homer accounted for three of those runs on one swing. Louisville out-hit Toledo by more than 2:1 but went scoreless over the final five innings after Wolf's exit. The Bats left six runners on base and went 2-for-7 with runners in scoring position.
What It Means
Toledo (55-61) levelled the six-game series at two wins apiece heading into the finale. Louisville (58-57) dropped to one game above .500 for the first time since July. The Bats have now lost two of their last three and face a deciding game on Sunday — Brandon Williamson (0-1, 13.50) versus Dylan File (6-7, 5.27) at 1:05 PM at Louisville Slugger Field.
Verdict
A game that belonged to Louisville's pitching for five innings was stolen by one swing from Anderson. The Bats' inability to add insurance runs after their four-run fourth proved costly against a Toledo side that made three hits count for more than Louisville's seven.
Rivalry since 2024
Louisville Bats vs Toledo Mud Hens Head to Head Results· 50
Louisville Bats and Toledo Mud Hens have met 50 times — Louisville Bats won 18, Toledo Mud Hens won 32, with 0 draws. Their rivalry dates back to 2024. Toledo Mud Hens leads the head-to-head with 32 victories from 50 meetings. A combined 525 goals have been scored across these fixtures, averaging 10.50 per match (222 for the home side, 303 for the visitors). Both teams scored in 43 matches (86%). Over 2.5 goals landed in 47 games (94%), making it a fixture that tends to produce goals. Louisville Bats are currently unbeaten in the last 3 meetings. The highest-scoring encounter finished 18–4 in 2026.
Statistics are for informational purposes only. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
API data: 17 Aug 2026