Match Summary
Columbus Crew defeated New York City FC 4:2. The match was played in Major League Soccer 2024. Goals were scored by A. Martínez 4′, D. Rossi 17′, M. Arfsten 58′, M. Bakrar 86′, D. Jones 90′, J. Russell-Rowe 90′. 3 yellow cards were shown, 1 red cards. Columbus Crew had 46% possession while New York City FC held 54%. Columbus Crew had 13 shots (6 on target) compared to 16 (6 on target) for New York City FC. Expected goals: Columbus Crew 3.04 — New York City FC 1.20. Columbus Crew made 6 substitutions, New York City FC made 6. VAR was involved: Penalty cancelled (Diego Rossi 52′).
Match Events
Key match events between Columbus Crew and New York City FC — 6 goals and 4 cards recorded during the match.
assist: T. Gray
assist: C. Ramirez
assist: D. Rossi
assist: A. Mățan
Match Statistics
Columbus Crew had 46% possession against New York City FC's 54%. Columbus Crew registered 13 shots (6 on target) while New York City FC managed 16 (6 on target). Corner kicks: 4–8. Fouls committed: 9–14.
Lineups
Columbus Crew lined up in a 3-4-2-1 formation under W. Nancy, while New York City FC deployed a 4-2-3-1 under N. Cushing.
Squad Ratings
The overall squad rating for Columbus Crew is 7.05, compared to 6.92 for New York City FC. This metric is derived from each player's average match rating across all league appearances this season — anything above 7.00 is considered strong, while below 6.50 signals inconsistency. Columbus Crew's highest-rated starter is M. Arfsten (7.41), while New York City FC's best-rated player is M. Freese (7.04).
Attacking Output
The starting XI of Columbus Crew have contributed 8 goals and 8 assists this season, led by M. Arfsten (5G). New York City FC's starters account for 20 goals and 7 assists, spearheaded by A. Martínez (19G). Goals reflect clinical finishing and chance creation, while assists highlight the ability to unlock defences through through-balls, crosses, and set pieces.
Defensive Solidity
Columbus Crew deploy 3 defenders rated 6.90 on average, against New York City FC's 4-man backline averaging 6.89. Higher defensive ratings suggest better positional awareness, fewer individual errors, and a greater likelihood of keeping clean sheets. The rating accounts for tackles won, interceptions, aerial duels, and blocks throughout the season.
Midfield Control
Columbus Crew field 4 midfielders averaging 7.16, versus New York City FC's 5 rated 6.79. Midfield ratings reflect passing accuracy, interceptions, key passes, and overall control of possession — the team that dominates midfield typically dictates the tempo and territory of the match.
Forward Threat
Columbus Crew start 3 forward(s) averaging —, compared to 1 for New York City FC averaging 7.00. Forward ratings capture shot accuracy, movement off the ball, dribbling success, and involvement in build-up play — they indicate who carries the greater goal threat on the day.
Passing & Build-Up
Passing accuracy averages 56% for Columbus Crew and —% for New York City FC. Higher passing accuracy generally indicates a possession-based style with patient build-up through the thirds, while lower figures may suggest a more direct, counter-attacking approach with long balls and quick transitions.
Discipline
Columbus Crew's starters have collected 18 yellow cards this season, compared to 22 for New York City FC. Yellow cards reflect how aggressively a team presses and tackles — a high count may indicate a physical, high-pressing style but also risks suspensions and late free-kicks in dangerous areas.
Age & Experience
The average age of Columbus Crew's starting XI is 27.8 (youngest: P. Schulte (24), oldest: D. Nagbe (35)), while New York City FC average 25.0 (youngest: A. Ojeda (21), oldest: M. Freese (27)). Younger squads typically offer pace, energy, and pressing intensity, while experienced lineups bring composure, game management, and the ability to handle high-pressure moments.
Squad Depth
Columbus Crew's starters average 30 league appearances each, versus 32 for New York City FC. High appearance counts indicate an established, well-drilled unit that the manager trusts week in and week out. Lower figures may suggest rotation, injuries, or emerging players still earning their place in the team.
Substitutes
Substitutes
Recent Form
In their last 6 matches, Columbus Crew have recorded 2 wins, 1 draws and 3 defeats. New York City FC show 3 wins, 1 draws and 2 losses from their last 6 outings.
Columbus Crew
New York City FC
Head to Head
Columbus Crew and New York City FC have met 2 times — Columbus Crew won 0, New York City FC won 1, with 1 draws. Their rivalry dates back to 2025. New York City FC leads the head-to-head with 1 victories from 2 meetings. A combined 5 goals have been scored across these fixtures, averaging 2.50 per match (2 for the home side, 3 for the visitors). Both teams scored in 1 matches (50%). Over 2.5 goals landed in 1 games (50%), making it a fixture that tends to produce goals. The highest-scoring encounter finished 3–2 in 2025.
0
Columbus Crew
1
Drawn
1
New York City FC
Recent Meetings (2)
API data: 15 Mar 2026