Full Time
Major League Soccer· Season 2016
17 April 2016 at 00:30MAPFRE Stadium, Columbus
Referee: Ted Unkel
Match Summary
Columbus Crew defeated New York City FC 3:2. The match was played in Major League Soccer 2016.
Rivalry since 2015
Columbus Crew vs New York City FC Head to Head Results· 29
Columbus Crew and New York City FC have met 29 times — Columbus Crew won 11, New York City FC won 11, with 7 draws. Their rivalry dates back to 2015. A combined 95 goals have been scored across these fixtures, averaging 3.28 per match (45 for the home side, 50 for the visitors). Both teams scored in 20 matches (69%). Over 2.5 goals landed in 19 games (66%), making it a fixture that tends to produce goals. The highest-scoring encounter finished 4–2 in 2024.
Total goals
95 · 3.3/match
Both scored
20/29 · 69%
Over 2.5
19/29 · 66%
Statistics are for informational purposes only. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
API data: 14 May 2026