NCAA· Season 2026
Anthony Grigsby Jr. threw for 319 yards and 4 TDs, finding Tayvion McCoy for a 34-yard game-winner with 9 seconds left as Cal Poly stunned Idaho 38-34.
Match Videos
Match Analysis
AI SummaryHow It Unfolded
Cal Poly controlled the first half behind Grigsby's arm. He connected with tight end Alek Marshall for a 17-yard score on the opening drive, found running back Misa Paiau for a 1-yard touchdown to cap a 16-play, 75-yard march, then hit wideout Fidel Pitts from 16 yards out to push the lead to 21-10 at the break.
Idaho's Ferrari Miller answered the Paiau touchdown with a 7-yard run, but the Vandals managed only two Forsman field goals in the third quarter — a 40-yarder and a 44-yarder — to trim the deficit to 21-16.
Noah Thayer extended Cal Poly's lead to 24-16 with a 28-yard field goal early in the fourth. Then the fireworks began.
The Turning Point
Idaho quarterback Joshua Wood engineered two lightning-quick touchdown drives. First he found Tony Harste for a 5-yard score, then the duo connected again on a 75-yard bomb on the next drive — both inside a 2:38 span — flipping a 24-16 deficit into a 31-24 Vandals lead with 3:38 to play.
But Grigsby answered in 3:54, capping a 65-yard drive with a 15-yard scramble for the tying touchdown. Forsman's third field goal of the night, a 40-yarder with 63 seconds left, appeared to have given Idaho the win.
Cal Poly started at its own 23. Grigsby hit McCoy for 41 yards, then again to reach the Idaho 36. On fourth-and-eight, with the game on the line, Grigsby found McCoy on a 34-yard touchdown pass over the middle. McCoy fought through a tackle attempt and stretched the ball across the goal line.
Key Performers
Anthony Grigsby Jr., Cal Poly — 26-of-35, 319 yards, 4 TD, 0 INT; also rushed for a 15-yard TD. The senior quarterback accounted for five touchdowns in Skipper's debut.
Tayvion McCoy, Cal Poly — 10 catches, 170 yards, two touchdowns including the game-winner. The transfer made an immediate impact in his first game with the Mustangs.
Joshua Wood, Idaho — Passed for 363 yards and two touchdowns. His 75-yard connection with Harste was the longest play of the game.
Tony Harste, Idaho — Two touchdown catches (5 yards, 75 yards) as Wood's primary target in the fourth-quarter rally.
Owen Forsman, Idaho — Three field goals (23, 40, 44 yards), giving the Vandals a late lead with 63 seconds left.
By the Numbers
Cal Poly outgained Idaho 516-482 in total yards, led by a 197-119 advantage on the ground. The Mustangs dominated time of possession (32:26 to 27:34) and converted 29 first downs to Idaho's 18. Despite throwing for 44 more yards, Idaho couldn't stop Grigsby on third down — Cal Poly converted 4 of 5 third-down attempts.
What It Means
Cal Poly (1-0, 1-0 Big Sky) won its first game against Idaho since transitioning to FCS before the 1994 season, snapping a five-game losing streak in the series. Skipper earned the victory in his head-coaching debut. The game set a program attendance record of 11,186 at Mustang Memorial Field, where John Madden's No. 74 was retired at halftime — only the second retired jersey in Cal Poly football history.
Idaho (0-1, 0-1) fell despite outscoring Cal Poly 18-17 in the fourth quarter. The Vandals next face (opponent TBD).
Up next: Cal Poly hosts Division II Central Washington on Saturday, Sept. 5 (5 p.m. PT).
Verdict
A season opener that delivered Big Sky theatre: 24 combined points in the final 6:31, four lead changes in the fourth quarter, and a walk-off touchdown on fourth down. Grigsby's poise — 319 yards, zero turnovers, and a game-winning dart on fourth-and-eight — announced Cal Poly as a conference factor under Skipper. Idaho's rally, undone by a defence that couldn't get off the field on the final drive, leaves questions about closing out games.
Cal Poly and Idaho have met 2 times — Cal Poly won 0, Idaho won 2, with 0 draws. Their rivalry dates back to 2023. Idaho leads the head-to-head with 2 victories from 2 meetings. A combined 119 goals have been scored across these fixtures, averaging 59.50 per match (43 for the home side, 76 for the visitors). Both teams scored in 2 matches (100%). Over 2.5 goals landed in 2 games (100%), making it a fixture that tends to produce goals. The highest-scoring encounter finished 34–29 in 2024.
Statistics are for informational purposes only. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
API data: 30 Aug 2026
